Man accused of killing Atlanta-area police officer may have been spotted

Officer shot in Atlanta area community

By CNN'S DEANNA HACKNEY, KEITH ALLEN, STEVE ALMASY AND ELIOTT C. MCLAUGHLIN CONTRIBUTED TO THIS REPORT.
Elvis Santana/freeimages.com

(CNN) - Police searching for a man charged with killing a police officer said there has been a "credible sighting" of the suspect in Snellville, Georgia, sometime late Sunday or early Monday.

Gwinnett County Police tweeted at 9 a.m. ET Monday that someone had seen Tafahree Maynard in the previous 12 hours.

Maynard, 18, has been charged with aggravated assault and felony murder in the Saturday afternoon killing of officer Antwan Toney near Snellville, authorities said.

Sgt. Jake Smith, Gwinnett police spokesman, said Sunday that several locations in the area were checked. A SWAT team executed a search warrant at the home of a suspected associate of Maynard, near the initial location of the shooting, Smith said.

"He's still at large as far as we're concerned," Smith said.

A second suspect, Isaiah Pretlow, 19, was arrested and has been charged with aggravated assault, police said.

Toney, 30, was responding to an anonymous 911 call reporting a suspicious vehicle parked near Shiloh Middle School when he was killed, Police Chief Butch Ayers said. The caller believed the vehicle occupants might have been smoking marijuana.

The officer was approaching the car when, police say, Maynard fired a weapon from inside the vehicle and struck him. Another officer returned fire and dragged Toney away. He died at a hospital, Smith said.

Police have not released details about Toney's injuries and have not said whether anyone in the suspects' car was hit or how many shots were fired.

After the shooting, the suspects' four-door black sedan sped away and crashed about a mile away. The suspects fled.

"They fled the scene and crashed without an officer in hot pursuit," Smith said.

Police believe Pretlow was driving the car and that as many as four people were inside.

At some point after running from the car, Pretlow pointed a gun at an officer, and the officer fired his weapon at him, police said. Pretlow, who was not injured, is facing an aggravated assault charge stemming from that encounter.

He ran to a wooded area but was arrested hours later by federal marshals, police said.

Police presence was heavy Saturday evening in neighborhoods a few miles east of Stone Mountain as officers, SWAT and K-9 teams searched for those who fled the car. A helicopter flew above the vicinity of the middle school.

Officer was 'a jovial person'

Toney, who was originally from Southern California, had been with the department for almost three years.

His visitation is scheduled for Tuesday at a Peachtree Corners funeral home, and his funeral will be held Wednesday at a Lawrenceville church, Gwinnett County Police said in a tweet.

Before Toney was an officer, he had been a security guard, police said.

His Gwinnett colleagues "recall a very jovial person who was dedicated to his job and dedicated to his community," Ayers said.

A memorial was set up in front of police headquarters in Lawrenceville and flags there were at half-staff.

Gwinnett County is in the metropolitan Atlanta area and has 920,000 residents. Toney's killing is the first in-the-line-of-duty death in the county since May 1993, when an officer was killed in a traffic incident. Three officers were shot to death in April 1964.

Toney's death was the second fatal shooting of a law enforcement officer in the span of a few days. North Carolina State Trooper Kevin K. Conner was killed Wednesday during a traffic stop near the South Carolina border. A suspect was taken into custody.

Smith urged anyone with information about the shooting or Maynard's whereabouts to call the police tip line at (770) 513-5710. Smith said Crime Stoppers is offering a $5,000 reward for anyone with information. Tipsters can remain anonymous.

Copyright 2018 by CNN NewSource. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.