Convicted Kissimmee cop killer wants death recommendation thrown out Attorneys say jurors were given ‘defective’ instructions
OSCEOLA COUNTY, Fla. – A man convicted of fatally shooting two Kissimmee police officers wants the jury’s death sentence recommendation thrown out, according to court records.
Everett Miller’s attorneys recently filed a 70-page motion asking that the death recommendation be set aside and that a new trial and sentencing proceeding be held. The documents also seek arrest of judgment and the opportunity to interview jurors.
Miller’s sentencing is set for Dec. 20.
[EVERETT MILLER TRIAL: State paints bloodied picture of night two Kissimmee police officers were killed | Defense rests after accused cop killer’s sister testifies on his behalf ]
Attorneys allege that the jurors were given “defective” instructions and “zero guidance” about mitigating factors.
State prosecutors denied that was the case in a six-page response.
Miller was convicted of killing Kissimmee Sgt. Sam Howard and Officer Matthew Baxter in 2017.
Copyright 2019 by WKMG ClickOrlando - All rights reserved.
Man sought after deadly shooting near Leesburg homeless camp, deputies say ▶ 0:54
Man sought after deadly shooting near Leesburg homeless camp, deputies say
Ulta Beauty World 2026: Amazing Finds & Must-Have Products! ▶ 0:58
Ulta Beauty World 2026: Amazing Finds & Must-Have Products!
New Smyrna Beach residents turn to ancient Florida rock for new seawall ▶ 0:51
New Smyrna Beach residents turn to ancient Florida rock for new seawall
New Ulta Beauty Exclusive: Summer Must-Haves Revealed! ▶ 0:46
New Ulta Beauty Exclusive: Summer Must-Haves Revealed!
News 6 goes behind the scenes of Blue Man Theater ahead of opening night ▶ 0:40
News 6 goes behind the scenes of Blue Man Theater ahead of opening night
A look inside Ulta Beauty World! So many brands, so little time. ▶ 1:09
A look inside Ulta Beauty World! So many brands, so little time.
Ulta Expo: New York in Orlando ▶ 1:02
Ulta Expo: New York in Orlando
Florists faced with tough choices for Mother's Day deliveries. How to save money ▶ 0:39
Florists faced with tough choices for Mother's Day deliveries. How to save money
Ulta Beauty World: Here are some of the products we saw ▶ 0:57
Ulta Beauty World: Here are some of the products we saw
Inside Ulta Beauty World: News 6 takes you behind the scenes ▶ 0:32
Inside Ulta Beauty World: News 6 takes you behind the scenes
🤘We got a taste of the Rock ‘n’ Roller Coaster Starring The Muppets soundtrack. ▶ 0:49
🤘We got a taste of the Rock ‘n’ Roller Coaster Starring The Muppets soundtrack.
Call it the Super Bowl of beauty: Ulta Beauty World ▶ 1:31
Call it the Super Bowl of beauty: Ulta Beauty World
Waymo expands driverless ride-hailing to all Orlando riders ▶ 1:16
Waymo expands driverless ride-hailing to all Orlando riders
Who would pay for more lifeguards? ▶ 0:45
Who would pay for more lifeguards?
Golden ticket to Ulta Expo ▶ 0:33
Golden ticket to Ulta Expo
Central Florida counties work to align on $33 million McCulloch Road project ▶ 1:01
Central Florida counties work to align on $33 million McCulloch Road project
Daytona Beach wedding venue suddenly closes without warning to couples ▶ 0:55
Daytona Beach wedding venue suddenly closes without warning to couples
Teacher accused of having relationship with 17-year-old ▶ 0:36
Teacher accused of having relationship with 17-year-old
What happened to their tax refund?! ▶ 1:10
What happened to their tax refund?!
Artemis II’s grand moon finale ▶ 0:47
Artemis II’s grand moon finale
A primal way to maintain mental health ▶ 1:30
A primal way to maintain mental health
Volusia County defends beach renourishment after rough surf carves small cliffs into coastline ▶ 0:57
Volusia County defends beach renourishment after rough surf carves small cliffs into coastline
Is it still a crime to use chalk on the crosswalk next to Pulse? ▶ 1:04
Is it still a crime to use chalk on the crosswalk next to Pulse?
Student video shows train clipping a Sumter County school bus ▶ 0:15
Student video shows train clipping a Sumter County school bus
Orange County deputies investigating shooting near UCF ▶ 0:40
Orange County deputies investigating shooting near UCF
Previous photo Next photo