‘I need my gun back:’ Man accused of running from Casselberry gun range with stolen handgun

Brendan Ogarro, 22, faces charge of grand theft

Brendan Ogarro, 22 (Seminole County Jail, Casselberry Police Department)

CASSELBERRY, Fla. – An Altamonte Springs man was arrested on Tuesday after a gun was stolen from a gun shop in Casselberry, according to the police department.

In a release, police said they were called to the Shoot Straight gun shop and shooting range after the firearm was reported stolen around 12:05 p.m.

Recommended Videos



The suspect was described as a man wearing a pink hoodie and jeans, and he reportedly ran out of the store with a Rugar EC9S handgun without paying, police added.

[EXCLUSIVE: Become a News 6 Insider (it’s FREE) | PINIT! Share your photos]

Upon arrival at the store, police found an employee out in front of the shop shouting, “He started running that way,” while looking toward southbound U.S. Highway 17-92, an arrest report states.

After searching around, police eventually found a man — later identified as Brendan Ogarro, 22 — a few blocks away, walking in front of the City Buffet along Live Oaks Boulevard, the report says.

Police eventually located Ogarro, though he fled on foot, the release says. (Casselberry Police Department)

The release shows that Ogarro “refused to comply” with officers’ commands, instead fleeing on foot.

However, one officer chased after him and managed to catch Ogarro, investigators said. Officers reported they found a pink hoodie and a Rugar EC9S in Ogarro’s jeans.

While he was being secured, Ogarro repeatedly stated, “I need my gun back,” the arrest report reads.

Officers chased after Ogarro and ultimately took him into custody, according to the Casselberry Police Department. (Casselberry Police Department)

Police said Ogarro was taken to the hospital due to a “road rash” he suffered, and while there, he told detectives that he had gone to Shoot Straight from his house “because I was bored” and had planned to purchase the Rugar.

In addition, while Ogarro had initially identified himself as “Pedro,” he later told fire officials his real name, the arrest report says.

The firearm was ultimately returned to Shoot Straight.

Ogarro faces charges of grand theft of a firearm, giving false identification to law enforcement, and two counts of resisting officers without violence. He is held on bond of $4,000.

Get today’s headlines in minutes with Your Florida Daily:


About the Author

Anthony, a graduate of the University of Florida, joined ClickOrlando.com in April 2022.

Recommended Videos