Madeline Soto’s mother feared ‘Woody Allen situation’ between boyfriend and daughter Episode 6 – ‘Justice for Madeline: What Does Mom Know?’
ORANGE COUNTY, Fla. – As detectives were searching for missing 13-year-old Madeline Soto last winter, Soto’s mother expressed concerns about the close relationship that had formed between her 37-year-old former boyfriend, Stephan Sterns , and her young daughter.
“I’ve always told (Sterns) that my biggest fear is that this would turn into a ‘Woody Allen situation’ where… the child turns 18 and ends up running away with him,” Jennifer Soto explained to detectives .
Soto was apparently referring to the filmmaker and actor’s 1997 marriage to the adopted daughter of his former girlfriend, Mia Farrow.
[TIMELINE: Here’s where things stand in the Madeline Soto case 10 months later ]
Sterns has pleaded not guilty to charges of sexually battering and murdering Madeline Soto.
In Part 6 of “Justice for Madeline ”, detectives question Jennifer Soto about what they describe as the family’s “weird” living situation less than an hour before the Kissimmee teen’s body is found.
All episodes of “Justice for Madeline” can be found here :
VIDEO
Get today’s headlines in minutes with Your Florida Daily :
Copyright 2025 by WKMG ClickOrlando - All rights reserved.
About the Author Mike DeForest headshot
Emmy Award-winning investigative reporter Mike DeForest has been covering Central Florida news for more than two decades.
‘Breaking Bad on steroids:’ Florida sheriff details seizure of 92,000 pounds of drugs, arsenal of weapons ▶ 0:57
‘Breaking Bad on steroids:’ Florida sheriff details seizure of 92,000 pounds of drugs, arsenal of weapons
Orlando pastry chef brings Brazilian flavors to Food Network’s ‘Holiday Baking Championship’ ▶ 1:03
Orlando pastry chef brings Brazilian flavors to Food Network’s ‘Holiday Baking Championship’
🌳Discover the Orlando Tree Trek Adventure Park: Family-friendly aerial adventure minutes from Disney ▶ 1:16
🌳Discover the Orlando Tree Trek Adventure Park: Family-friendly aerial adventure minutes from Disney
Tavares eyes fines, permits for garage sale violations ▶ 0:48
Tavares eyes fines, permits for garage sale violations
Central Florida’s newest Trader Joe’s is officially open!🛒✨ ▶ 0:48
Central Florida’s newest Trader Joe’s is officially open!🛒✨
A Door Dash driver uses the 5-second rule on some unknowing customers. It’s caught on a doorbell camera. ▶ 1:26
A Door Dash driver uses the 5-second rule on some unknowing customers. It’s caught on a doorbell camera.
Secret Service launches crackdown on EBT fraud, targets credit card skimmers ▶ 0:35
Secret Service launches crackdown on EBT fraud, targets credit card skimmers
Port Canaveral now the most-visited cruise terminal in the world, leaders announce ▶ 0:47
Port Canaveral now the most-visited cruise terminal in the world, leaders announce
1 injured in Sanford house fire ▶ 0:47
1 injured in Sanford house fire
Most powerful rocket ever made coming to KSC ▶ 0:59
Most powerful rocket ever made coming to KSC
Cyber Monday shifts to Giving Tuesday as Salvation Army to host world’s largest red kettle at Cranes Roost Park ▶ 0:50
Cyber Monday shifts to Giving Tuesday as Salvation Army to host world’s largest red kettle at Cranes Roost Park
Who would do a thing like this? Enormous Christmas bulbs missing from downtown Melbourne display ▶ 0:40
Who would do a thing like this? Enormous Christmas bulbs missing from downtown Melbourne display
SunRail expands late-night service with 2 new trains. Here’s what to know ▶ 1:04
SunRail expands late-night service with 2 new trains. Here’s what to know
Amazon in Orlando expects almost double the packages for Cyber Monday ▶ 0:41
Amazon in Orlando expects almost double the packages for Cyber Monday
‘Stand Your Ground’ cited after fatal Seminole County shooting stems from apparent road rage ▶ 0:49
‘Stand Your Ground’ cited after fatal Seminole County shooting stems from apparent road rage
A Door Dash driver uses the 5-second rule on some unknowing customers. It’s caught on a doorbell camera. ▶ 1:26
A Door Dash driver uses the 5-second rule on some unknowing customers. It’s caught on a doorbell camera.
Healthcare relief for thousands of Seniors in The Villages ▶ 0:30
Healthcare relief for thousands of Seniors in The Villages
‘Just feels magical:’ How Park Avenue in Winter Park gets its holiday glow-up ▶ 0:26
‘Just feels magical:’ How Park Avenue in Winter Park gets its holiday glow-up
Warm start to week before Thanksgiving cooldown in Central Florida. Here’s the timing ▶ 0:59
Warm start to week before Thanksgiving cooldown in Central Florida. Here’s the timing
‘The Midnight Stalker:’ Mystery surrounds masked person leaving wood, money on Florida front porches ▶ 0:58
‘The Midnight Stalker:’ Mystery surrounds masked person leaving wood, money on Florida front porches
Shots fired at Deltona home after attempted break-in, deputies say ▶ 0:45
Shots fired at Deltona home after attempted break-in, deputies say
Sisters find mother’s Ocala apartment emptied days after her death ▶ 0:29
Sisters find mother’s Ocala apartment emptied days after her death
16-year-old stepbrother ‘is a suspect’ in Titusville teen’s death on cruise ship, court documents show ▶ 0:26
16-year-old stepbrother ‘is a suspect’ in Titusville teen’s death on cruise ship, court documents show
Pregnancy and parking: Florida’s new law could make finding spots harder ▶ 0:43
Pregnancy and parking: Florida’s new law could make finding spots harder
Roblox steps up age checks and groups younger users into age-based chats ▶ 0:31
Roblox steps up age checks and groups younger users into age-based chats
Previous photo Next photo 